Why have the gospels made many claims that are contradicted by historical records? - brief cover note examples
The Gospels make many contradictory statements, the historical data
Unlike the Old Testament, which covers a period of hundreds if not thousands of years covering the New Testament writings a certain time is very short. Most books will make no statement of historic significance, the control also with the historical record, but the Gospels and the Acts, some of them. Acts is now recognized by many experts as a myth, even though some aspects may be based loosely on true events.
Of greatest significance are the gospels. Although the Gospels cover a short-term, there are some indications that are made, which can be checked with the known historical data. It should be noted that the Gospels, of course, get the story in itself. Herod was a king of truth, Pontius Pilate was governor of Judea and Galilee Royal is a real place, but also the basis for some of the details that are part of the Gospels are completely without evidence or conflictingED by the evidence we have. Here are some examples of claims in the Gospels are to be made from the facts of history or the gospels unconfirmed contradicted.
* "Star of Bethlehem" - No such a celestial event that can trace the St. Matthew Gospel.
* Roman census of the birth of Jesus - There is no indication of a census that this description fits.
* "The Massacre of the Innocents" - A replay of the event outside the Gospel of Matthew.
* John the Baptist - killed at the beginning of the gospel, who died in 36 CE according to Josephus.
* Accompanies the death of Jesus - after the failure of the sun, earthquakes, and the resurrection of the dead in the Gospels, there is no trace of such by others.
Wednesday, January 20, 2010
Brief Cover Note Examples Why Have The Gospels Made Many Claims That Are Contradicted By Historical Records?
10 comments:
There is no contradiction. Not everything was written in history. It is absurd to claim that we have everything that has happened in history, or that someone had to consciously write it to be.
"Star of Bethlehem" is in Matthew's Gospel unknown. He had said: "You heard the king, they departed, and lo, the star they see in the East went before them, till it came and stood over where the child was." It is possible that these ways the "stars" or the alignment of the planets, etc., recognized as a "sign", but not others.
Census: The Romans no record of everything they did. It could be that "census" not the best translation because it more as an introduction. O records can be lost if it has ever been.
Massacre of the Innocents: Lack of outside Mateo. So what? Bethlehem was a small village, probably not that many children are killed (even if one too many), fOre, it is doubtful that a journalist had to walk alongside soldiers in this task. ROME systematically kill anyone who crossed his path. Who knows how many years? Romans did not always have the great expecially murdered.
John the Baptist: Josephus was not the same with John the Baptist and could be estimated. In addition, the ministry of Jesus about 3 1 / 2 years was long, and John the Baptist was the beginning of Jesus' ministry today. In any case, there are only three bays long throughout the year .. I'm not sure what you mean by the "premature death." The fact is that you refer Josephus - this means that Josephus has confirmed that a Jean-Baptiste.
The death of Jesus: Where are all the variety of weather records at the time, hmmm? You keep no record of weather conditions at the time, and most countries this is attributed to the death of a person to be crucified as a criminal, though, right? Outside of Jerusalem, knew just what happened then. JuGospel and authors have attributed this as a "sign" because it was an important event for them.
The resurrection of the dead - including the authors of the Gospels, it is likely that no matter * which * just happened, and resurrection are a sign.
I think you enter here ...
Like any great work of fiction, and that sucks, you have to believe what is written. The Bible is a fraud to unsuspecting masses who need counseling because they do not function without someone or something to give meaning and direction in their lives, the poor fools who are false.
I think the answer speaks for Christians in general and to respond to five, in particular, what is the reason that yesterday was a frog into a prince, I can not provide proof that you are doing, and I believe. In fact, in its reasonable as trying an intelligent conversation with a parrot that can talk, but there is no backup
A major earthquake recorded in Israel in 31 BC, the oldest historically documented disasters in the region.
http://landscapelearning.wordpress.com/2007/12/10/dead-sea-earthquakes-history-archaeology-and-a-doomsday-prediction/
^^^^^^ Lol
Contradictions without my a $ $.
The Gospels are full of contradictions, too many to count them.
Not sure what you're talking about when these statements.
"Massacre of the Innocents"
If you mean the fire of Nero, is mentioned in the Bible, you should know that it really happened.
If you want to talk about the incident with King Herod, you should know that Syria has produced texts describe this event. These texts speak of how Herod killed more than 64,000 children. This text was written many years after the death of Herod, but that does not necessarily mean that it happened. For example, Tacitus, which documented the fire of Nero, and a biography of Alexander the Great, was not written only four years after his death.
Historians do not have enough evidence to say that "murder of innocent children" occurred. In this sense it is more than a legend when the real story so far. Important, however, does not mean it's happened, I doubt it.
The story of Matthew describes as a cruel King Herod. Historians agree that King Herod was a king, very brutaltake anyone who challenges him. He also appreciated the public execution of people and the mass slaughter, which he saw as a threat. Thus, the biblical story of Herod's personality is compatible with historical accounts.
Knowing this, I have no doubt that King Herod.
I agree with the first post here.
They say that the contradictions. . however, only shows that you have done your homework.
* * Illustration on a football field. If you are on the fence at the end of the goal of selecting the right place. . can focus on a vision of the game that you can see, only 1 When moving for a moment without moving, you are still standing. . You see only one post. . . then moves slightly towards the middle of the grandstand. . You see 2 posts, but always together. If you are at the other end of the goal post at an angle of 90 degrees () from the front, two positions will be distributed properly. Now, the seats did not budge. . But you need to get the full picture.
If yours the seeming contradictions in the Bible. . need to relax and study with some questions in mind to delete the image. (You may need your attitude, change to admire the view)
First. . wonder who wrote it? . . Who? . . Why? . . then look in the global context. . taking into account the culture and understanding of theseto read if it was written. We have different cultural perspectives today. . But that does not mean that your old culture wrong. . just different.
I have seen on the hardened debater displayed correctly when to say what they mitigate is a contradiction. Read just a little more. . and the understanding of time and the authors of these pages.
There are no contradictions.
After a long time studied the Roman era, I can say that there is so little material available to know the real history of the claim.
But we take what we already proposed:
Identify 1 - the stars, so we speak (if you can not, can not claim that there is a contradiction)
2 - Josephus confirms the identification
3 - Herod the Great, thousands of people killed in the last 6 months of life. Child of Bethlehem is not big news.
Do not give 4 - Josephus, a date for the death of John. In fact, it's a long paragraph. (Incidentally, the data from the Whiston translation of Josephus 'Archeology', which can be at least 3 years. You get a better source.)
5 - No registration means no opposition. A balance contradictory reality, we have found that "there was no earthquake" or "there was no darkness, and then we'll talk.
For your task:
Know what the word "contradictionNo means.
Pontis Pilate recognize as real, but had 1800 years to find the proof.of Pilates, his lack of that from people like you used for centuries ... The minutes of this period are extremely rare because most have been deliberately destroyed by the history, especially of Muslims in the early days .... to act as if there were masses of floating volumes omissions ... really do not want to believe and work hard to convince them that this is not true. Jesus loves you, even now, those who crucified him, and said my father, for they know not what they do ... suppress the faith, you have just read John's Gospel and heard what was said? These are the statements of the ether a fool or the incarnate Son of God ... If you have any questions, John, and things can find from there to prove something more than Jesus as the Son of God, bring it on ...
Post a Comment